And it’s that time of the year again – yes, love is in the air, and we can’t keep calm! While running out of gift ideas for that special someone, our editors came up with this brand new romantic gift idea – Valentine cookies for your special someone, freshly baked at home. And in case you can’t bake, we have managed to find two brands that will deliver your love! 

So, get your baking gloves ready and scroll down to read about the best cookies you can bake for your partner on Valentine’s Day!


7 Best Valentine Cookies Of All Time: Valentine’s Month Special

7 Best Valentine Cookies Of All Time Valentine's Month Special
Image Source

While Chocolate chip cookies have managed to stay in the number one spot for many years when it comes to picking the most popular cookie, this year, we plan on doing things a little differently. And no, we are not going to waste time discussing Valentine sugar cookies decorating ideas.

Instead, we have come up with some of the most unique types of Valentine cookies for your special someone. Stay tuned to find out!

Licorice Cookie

There are so many different types of Valentine cookies that you can bake for your partner or even purchase in case you can’t really bake. And our favorite one happens to be this really tasty Licorice cookie – these are super simple to bake and so delish that you won’t be able to resist! If you have a sweet tooth, it’s better to bake an extra batch for yourself. 

You will find how so many people do not really like Black licorice. But the strangest thing that happens is the aftermath of black licorice joining forces with chocolate. These aren’t your typical chocolate cookies – these taste sweet, salty, and complex, sometimes, quite surprisingly! 

Prep Time35 minutes
Total Time1 hour 40 minutes
Yields2 dozen
Sea Fairy Cookie
Image Source

For all fans of the Cookie Run kingdom, you all already know how legendary a Sea Fairy Cookie happens to be – after all, you just don’t get the Sea Fairy Cookie, you need to work for it! But what if we told you that you could bake these Sea Fairy Cookies at home for your partner on Valentine’s Day? 

Stop your ‘valentines cookies’ search and instead try baking these at home – love served DIY! These cookies are so pretty to stare at, and they taste even better. If your partner is not a fan of chocolate, then baking these sea fairy cookies is a great idea considering these don’t have any chocolate inside them. 

Prep Time20 minutes
Total Time1 hour
Yields2 dozen
Mocha Cookie Crumble Frappuccino
Image Source

While seeking the top ‘Valentine cookies decorated’ options sounds like a romantic plan, why not up the scales a little and choose something even better? How about Mocha Cookie Crumble frappuccino? Tasty, crunchy, and delish – yes, it’s not exactly a cookie. Rather it’s a shake? But who cares? Preparing something this tasty for your partner is so cute, we totally heart it!

Yes, you can head over to the nearest Starbucks and just end the matter there, but that won’t really count as romantic. Instead, how about heading over to your kitchen instead, and prepare this yummy beverage for your partner? We would totally appreciate this cookie-flavored love on Valentine’s day!

Prep Time5 minutes
Total Time10 minutes
Serves1 person

4. Great American Cookies

Great American Cookies
Image Source

Yes, we know how tasty those Pillsbury valentine cookies turned out to be – we don’t disagree! But have you ever tasted anything baked by the Great American Cookies? If you have tasted cookies from this brand, then there’s no point discussing how great these were, but if you haven’t, then this is the sign you were looking for! 

Not all of us are blessed with kickass baking skills, and as a result, it is only normal that you will opt to purchase freshly baked cookies from a well-known brand. And if that works for you, then simply check out Great American Cookies. The best part? You get these delivered to your doorstep!

Top OrdersDouble Doozies, Brownies, and Cookie Cakes
Stores370+ stores (up to 2022)

5. Insomnia Cookies

Insomnia Cookies
Image Source

While baking decorated Valentine cookies for your partner might sound like a delish idea, not all of us are blessed with crazy baking skills. For many of us, buying these cookies is a far better idea, and one place we most definitely love checking out is called Insomnia Cookies – yes, they are on Instagram and they are killing it! 

The best part? The brand’s unique selling proposition is delivering freshly baked warm cookies to their customer’s doorsteps. And that’s exactly what you need for celebrating the day of love – freshly baked, delish cookies at your partner’s doorstep! 

Top OrdersClassic with M&M’S, Chocolate Chunk Blondie, and Double Chocolate Mint
Stores215+ stores (up to 2021) 
Cream Unicorn Cookie
Image Source

In the Cookie Run kingdom, the cream unicorn cookie is a predator, a creep who loves to lock up kids just to play with them. But for Valentine’s Day, you can actually bake these cream unicorn cookies for your unsuspecting partner – and it will be such a great surprise if you think about it! 

We first tried these cookies out a while ago when a colleague experimented with the flavors at home. And we became fans – let everyone go buy a box of chocolate chip cookies while you can TRY baking a batch of Cream Unicorn cookies. Also, so easy to prep and even easier to bake – what more do you need? 

Prep Time30 minutes
Total Time40 minutes
Yields2 dozen
Heart-Shaped Sugar Cookie
Image Source

If you are searching for fancy-decorated valentine’s cookies to bake for your partner, then there’s no point ignoring these pretty heart-shaped sugar cookies. What can be sweeter than buying or even baking cute heart-shaped cookies? We are sold…aren’t you?

And the best part? You can opt for a nice frosting made from cream cheese or just go all out on buttercream. Additionally, you can make things more interesting by dyeing the frosting with any color – serve with some sprinkles on top! 

Prep Time30 minutes
Total Time1 hour 40 minutes
Yields2 dozen

Frequently Asked Questions:

Check out the most frequently asked questions about Valentine cookies mentioned below. 

Q1. What Is The Best Cookie Flavor?

Ans: The best cookie flavors in the world are as follows,
⦿ Snickerdoodle,
⦿ Peanut Butter,
⦿ Oatmeal Raisin,
⦿ Black & White,
⦿ Gingerbread,
⦿ Chocolate Chip,
⦿ White Chocolate Macadamia Nut, and
⦿ Sugar.

Q2. What Are The 7 Types Of Cookies?

Ans: The 7 types of cookies are as follows,
⦿ Sandwich Cookies,
⦿ Drop Cookies,
⦿ Filled Cookies,
⦿ Pressed Cookies,
⦿ Molded Cookies,
⦿ No Bake Cookies, and
⦿ Cookie Bars.

Q3. What Are The Top 10 Cookies In America?

Ans: The top ten cookies in America are as follows,
⦿ Peanut Butter Cookies,
⦿ Chocolate Chip Cookies,
⦿ Peanut Butter Blossoms,
⦿ Sugar Cookies,
⦿ Oatmeal Raisin Cookies,
⦿ Macaroons,
⦿ Molasses Cookies,
⦿ Classic No-Bake Cookies,
⦿ Cookie Cake, and
⦿ Lemon Cookies.

Q4. What Are The 6 Types Of Cookies?

Ans: The 6 types of cookies are as follows,
⦿ Molded Cookies,
⦿ Bar Cookies,
⦿ Pressed Cookies,
⦿ Refrigerator Cookies,
⦿ Rolled or Cutout Cookies, and
⦿ Drop Cookies.

And It’s A Wrap: 

So the search for the best Valentine cookies is now over! You might be wondering why we didn’t feature any of the usual cookies on this list – but why should we? Aren’t chocolate chip cookies so 2008? It’s a new year, and we, for one, are all about trying out new things, even when it comes to choosing the cookie recipe to try out on Valentine’s Day!

What about you? Did you like any of the cookies we talked about? Tell us in the comments below – don’t forget to let us know about your experiences with these cookies as well! 

Read Also:

What's your reaction?

In Love
Not Sure
Barsha Bhattacharya
Barsha Bhattacharya is a senior content writing executive. As a marketing enthusiast and professional for the past 4 years, writing is new to Barsha. And she is loving every bit of it. Her niches are marketing, lifestyle, wellness, travel and entertainment. Apart from writing, Barsha loves to travel, binge-watch, research conspiracy theories, Instagram and overthink.

    You may also like

    Leave a reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *